GUIDES

Building Annual Fund Pyramids Using AI

Simon Tumansky
March 18, 2025
5
min read

In a recent discussion, Mark Aimone, Director of Advancement at Wilbraham & Monson Academy, demonstrated how to leverage AI tools to create and manage gift pyramids for annual fund campaigns. Here's a breakdown of the key insights shared during his conversation with me.

Getting Started with AI for Gift Pyramids

Mark was initially resistant to AI tools, but became a convert after discovering their efficiency. Using ChatGPT, he demonstrates how to quickly build a gift pyramid for an annual fund campaign with a $1.2 million goal.

The process starts with a simple prompt: "Build a gift pyramid for an annual fund campaign with a goal of $1.2 million." He then refines the parameters by adding:

  • A top gift assumption of $150,000
  • A prospect-to-donor ratio of 4:1
The Power of Real-Time Adjustments

One of the most valuable aspects of using AI for gift pyramids is the ability to make real-time adjustments based on what you know about your donor pool. Mark demonstrates how to modify the pyramid when certain gift levels might not be achievable:

"Let's say that we can't get eight $25,000 gifts, but we could get twenty $10,000 gifts," Mark explains. By simply instructing the AI to "assume 20 gifts at $10,000 and zero gifts at $25,000," the tool recalculates the entire pyramid in seconds.

For schools just starting with annual funds, Mark suggests beginning with a realistic goal based on previous fundraising or capacity assessment. He demonstrates a smaller pyramid with a $150,000 goal, showing how the gift levels scale appropriately.

Beyond the Numbers: Using the Pyramid Strategically

Mark emphasizes that the pyramid itself is just a mathematical framework. The real value comes from how you use it to guide your fundraising strategy:

  1. Add prospect names to each gift level: Once you have the pyramid, add a column for prospect names at each giving level.
  2. Identify gaps: If you need 40 people to give $1,000 gifts but only have 30 prospects identified, you know where to focus your prospecting efforts.
  3. Develop personalized strategies: For top-tier gifts especially, develop individualized approaches for each prospect.
The Limitations of AI in Fundraising

When I  suggest having the AI recommend activities for each gift level, Mark highlights an important limitation: "AI doesn't personally know Prospect A, B, C, or D. I do. My staff does."

While AI can provide generic recommendations (like personal meetings for top prospects), users are cautioned against over-reliance on technology for the relationship aspects of fundraising:

"This is a personal business at the end of the day. It's one-on-one," Mark explains. "What's my rationale? What's my conversation? What's the donor interested in? What's my case for supporting the annual fund with this particular donor?"

Prerequisites for Effective Pyramid Building

Before building a gift pyramid, schools need:

Final Takeaway

The gift pyramid exercise isn't just about creating a mathematical model—it's about creating a roadmap for your fundraising strategy. It helps advancement teams visualize what's needed to reach their goal and prioritize their efforts accordingly.

"A gift pyramid is a way to help you see what you need to do to get to the end." - Mark Aimone

For advancement professionals looking to enhance their fundraising strategy using AI tools, this approach offers a practical starting point that combines technological efficiency with the necessary human element of fundraising.

Simon Tumansky
CEO & Founder
LinkedIn logo
March 18, 2025
5
min read